How do weak, misaligned tropical cyclones evolve towards alignment? A multi-case study using the Hurricane Analysis and Forecast System

The ability to predict whether and when a tropical cyclone will become vertically aligned is critical for intensity change forecasts, as storms can intensify quickly after achieving an aligned structure. A recent study from researchers at NOAA’s Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory and the University of Miami’s Cooperative Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Studies shows how weak, disorganized tropical cyclones containing different center locations with height, called misalignment, can develop a vertically aligned structure. This study works to improve forecasts of when this alignment might occur by identifying key times of the day and other tropical cyclone characteristics when alignment is likely.

When the center of a tropical cyclone is in roughly the same location throughout the atmosphere, the system is said to be vertically aligned. This alignment allows thunderstorms to develop completely around the center, protecting the system from the surrounding environment and therefore can be important for future tropical cyclone intensification.

HAFS-A domain outlined by (thick) black with the inset panel depicting a small boxed region covering parts of the Gulf of Mexico, NW Caribbean Sea, and far SW Atlantic. Black track lines (gray lines) within the inset indicate analyzed track periods (unanalyzed simulation periods) in this study including (1) Isaias, (2) Sally, (3) Ida, (4) Nicholas, and (5) Elsa.
Figure 1: HAFS-A domain outlined by (thick) black with the inset panel depicting a small boxed region covering parts of the Gulf of Mexico, NW Caribbean Sea, and far SW Atlantic. Black track lines (gray lines) within the inset indicate analyzed track periods (unanalyzed simulation periods) in this study including (1) Isaias, (2) Sally, (3) Ida, (4) Nicholas, and (5) Elsa.

To learn how tropical cyclones become aligned, researchers used NOAA’s next-generation hurricane forecast model, the Hurricane Analysis and Forecast System (HAFS), to simulate five different tropical cyclones from the 2020 and 2021 Atlantic hurricane seasons: Elsa, Ida, Isaias, Nicholas, and Sally [Figure 1]. These model runs were compared with radar and airborne observations to identify the model cycles that most accurately portrayed the observed tilt evolution. In all but one of these simulations, the tropical cyclone achieved a successful alignment of centers, which is what happened in reality. The results of this study can be used to better understand the processes leading to alignment and intensification of tropical cyclones.

Schematic demonstrating the vortex-scale processes responsible for a rapid evolvement from misalignment to alignment. Panel (A) shows the low-level center (LLC) displaced from the mid-level vortex with convection increasing near the MLC (indicated by the clouds). The increasing convection near the MLC occurs during the overnight to early morning hours of 11 p.m. to 3 a.m. (upper left), which also aligns with the diurnal maximum in TC convection (Ditchek, Molinari, et al., 2019; Dunion et al., 2014). At 3–6 a.m. local time (panel B), the boundaries between lower θE air from downdrafts (light blue shading) and warm, unstable air (higher θE air, light green shading) collide and initiate more intense, persistent convection. A new, compact low-mid level vorticity core forms near the convection and induces a low-level confluent inflow that brings more warm, moist air (light green shading) toward the new center fueling additional convection. The LLC rapidly migrates towards the reformed core during this time period.
Figure 2: Schematic demonstrating the vortex-scale processes responsible for a rapid evolvement from misalignment to alignment. Panel (A) shows the low-level center (LLC) displaced from the mid-level vortex with convection increasing near the MLC (indicated by the clouds). The increasing convection near the MLC occurs during the overnight to early morning hours of 11 p.m. to 3 a.m. (upper left), which also aligns with the diurnal maximum in TC convection (Ditchek, Molinari, et al., 2019; Dunion et al., 2014). At 3–6 a.m. local time (panel B), the boundaries between lower θE air from downdrafts (light blue shading) and warm, unstable air (higher θE air, light green shading) collide and initiate more intense, persistent convection. A new, compact low-mid level vorticity core forms near the convection and induces a low-level confluent inflow that brings more warm, moist air (light green shading) toward the new center fueling additional convection. The LLC rapidly migrates towards the reformed core during this time period.

Thunderstorms prefer to develop near the mid-level center of a misaligned tropical cyclone during the early morning hours [Figure 2, Panel A], which can help to start an alignment of the centers.

If thunderstorms persist for a long enough period of time, as air rises in these thunderstorms, it is replaced by inflow, which is air flowing toward the storm center from regions surrounding the storm that have greater heat and moisture [Figure 2, Panel B]. This causes the instability, or the ability of warm, moist air to rise and create thunderstorms, to increase.

Cool air from thunderstorm downdrafts flows outward when it hits the surface, creating boundaries with the warm, unstable air that was already there. These boundaries then push the warm, unstable air upward and initiate new thunderstorms that can grow and eventually form a new tropical cyclone center. This new center develops upward with the help of the thunderstorm growth and eventually “pulls in” the old, misaligned low-level center, which results in a vertically aligned tropical cyclone.

Citation: Alvey, G. R. III, & Hazelton, A. (2022). How do weak, misaligned tropical cyclones evolve toward alignment? A multi-case study using the Hurricane Analysis and Forecast System. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 127, e2022JD037268. https://doi.org/10.1029/2022JD037268