[Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory]

HRD Home
About AOML
About HRD
Data Sets
 yellow triangle bulletMission Catalog
 yellow triangle bulletSfc. Wind Anal.
 yellow triangle bulletSyn. Surveillance
 yellow triangle bulletRe-Anal. Proj.
 yellow triangle bulletBasin-Wide Data
 yellow triangle bulletData Formats
Weather Info
What's New

OAR Logo
NOAA Oceanic Atmospheric Research

NOAA Aircraft Operations Center Logo
NOAA Aircraft Operations Center

Site Map

Staff Data Center Contact  Information

Research Divisions

Hurricane Research Division
Why revise Hurricane Andrew ?

Hurricane Andrew's revision is a part of "The Atlantic Hurricane Database (HURDAT) Re-analysis Project" (NOAA/NASA Grant #GC02-093) that the author is Principal Investigator for. The goals of this project are to extend the database back in time and to revisit and possibly revise all of the tropical storms and hurricanes back to 1851 of the Atlantic Ocean, Gulf of Mexico and Caribbean Sea, including Hurricane Andrew. This database is utilized in a wide variety of ways: climatic change studies, seasonal forecasting, risk assessment for emergency managers, analysis of potential losses for insurance and business interests, and development/verification of official National Hurricane Center and compter model predictions of track and intensity.

Unfortunately, this Atlantic hurricane database contains many systematic and random errors that need correction. Additionally, as our understanding of hurricanes has developed, analysis techniques have changed over the years at NHC, leading to biases in the historical database that had not been addressed. Finally, recent efforts led by the late Jose Fernandez-Partagas to uncover previously undocumented historical hurricanes in the mid-1800s to early 1900s have greatly increased our knowledge of these past events, which also had not been incorporated into the hurricane database.

Andrew is just one of the hundreds of hurricanes that we are revising. It is a special case, naturally, because of the huge societal impact that it had in South Florida. While Hurricane Andrew would have been examined sequentially in this project sometime in late 2004 or early 2005, I was asked by the Director of NHC, Max Mayfield, to put Andrew at the front of the list for re-analysis because of its significance, because of the new research findings of the wind structure in strong hurricanes and because of its ten year anniversary.

One example of a very practical aspect of the outcome of Andrew's re-analysis is the potential impact on building codes and insurance rates. Previously, Hurricane Andrew was assessed as a Saffir-Simpson Category 4 hurricane hitting Southeast Florida (comprised of Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties). During the 20th Century when we have had relatively complete records, four Category 4 hurricanes were noted to have hit the area - Andrew, the 1926 Great Miami hurricane, the 1928 Lake Okeechobee hurricane and the 1947 Broward hurricane. This gave an average "return period" of 25 years (100 years/4 strikes) for the Southeast Florida for Category 4 hurricanes, though these occur rather unevenly within the 100 years. However, with Andrew being re-classified as a Category 5, this is the only one to have struck the area in (at least) 100 years. ("At least" because records before 1900 are too sketchy for confidence in the intensity of hurricanes that hit south Florida.) Thus the return period is equal to or greater than 100 years for a direct strike on the region by an Andrew-intensity (Category 5) hurricane.

So if one is interested in what the return period of extremely devastating hurricanes (as the public, government agencies, insurance companies and building code designers are), the category assigned is quite important. If - as it was until recently - Andrew is denoted a Category 4, then these are rare events (about four times in a century). But with Andrew being re-classified as a Category 5, this indicates that the type of destruction that Andrew caused is an extremely rare event - with a return period much longer than previously thought.

Certainly not all the changes to tropical storms and hurricanes in this re-analysis project are going to have as big an impact as Hurricane Andrew's. But the intensity and track assigned to Hurricane Andrew and the other 1273 tropical systems since 1851 is much more important than just keeping the records accurate. It should have a direct impact on how buildings are constructed and what insurance rates ought to be. Please feel free to contact me for more information about Hurricane Andrew's re-analysis or other storms that will be looked at in the database.

Chris Landsea, September 2002

Return to Upgrade page.
[Horizontal Rule]

[OAR/DOC/NOAA Logos] Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory Logo [United States Department of Commerce] [Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory] Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory Logo [National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration] [Office of Oceanic and Atmospheric Research] Department of Commerce Logo National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Logo Ocean and Atmospheric Research Logo

  Disclaimer | Privacy Policy